Explainer · Litigation

Third-country removals, and what the Supreme Court’s D.V.D. case means for Afghans.

The United States is deporting people to countries that are not their own and that no immigration judge named. On December 9, 2026, the Supreme Court hears Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., the case over how much warning and process those people get first. Here is how third-country removal works, where the case stands, and why it reaches Afghans who were told they would not be sent back to the Taliban.

Last updated November 17, 2026

In plain terms

The Supreme Court is not deciding whether Afghans can be deported to Afghanistan. It is deciding whether federal courts could require DHS to give people with final removal orders meaningful notice, and a real chance to raise a fear claim, before sending them to a country not named in their order. Until the Court rules, the government’s July 2025 procedures stay in effect.Congressional Research Service, “Immigration Removals to Third Countries,” In Focus IF13295, updated November 16, 2026; Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., No. 26-426 (U.S., certiorari granted September 29, 2026).

Start here

What a third-country removal is.

When an immigration judge orders someone removed, the order usually names a country, most often the person’s home country. A third-country removal sends the person somewhere else: a country they may have never lived in, have no status in, and whose language they may not speak.

The Immigration and Nationality Act sets the order in which countries are considered. A person can generally designate a country first. If that fails, the government looks to the country of citizenship, then to countries the person has ties to. Only when those are “impracticable, inadvisable, or impossible” may DHS turn to any other country willing to accept the person. Reasons the government gives for using a third country include home countries that refuse to accept their nationals or issue travel documents, caps on how many they take back, and poor diplomatic relations with the United States.

Two humanitarian protections limit where a person can be sent. Withholding of removal bars return to a country where the person’s life or freedom would be threatened. The Convention Against Torture bars transfer to a country where torture is more likely than not. Both are granted country by country. Federal regulations say a grant for one country does not bar removal to another.

DHS does not publish how many people it has sent to third countries or which agreements it has signed. Refugees International and Human Rights First, which track the practice jointly, estimate that as of September 2026 more than 25,000 people had been removed this way, under formal or informal arrangements with more than 30 countries. Their list includes Cameroon, Costa Rica, the Democratic Republic of Congo, El Salvador, Eswatini, Guatemala, Honduras, Panama, Paraguay, Poland, Uzbekistan, and Mexico, which has received the most. The Congressional Research Service describes current use as substantially exceeding past practice.

How it works now

The procedure ICE follows today.

A July 2025 memorandum from then-Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons sets the current steps. The Congressional Research Service summarizes them this way.

1

Diplomatic assurances come first

The United States checks whether the receiving country has promised not to persecute or torture people it accepts. If the State Department finds those assurances credible, the memo says the person “may be removed without the need for further procedures.”

2

Without assurances, a written notice

ICE serves a Notice of Removal naming the third country, in a language the person understands.

3

24 hours, or six

ICE generally waits at least 24 hours after the notice before removal. In “exigent circumstances,” which the memo does not define, it may remove after six hours with approval from senior DHS attorneys, so long as the person has a reasonable chance to speak with a lawyer.

4

The person must raise fear on their own

ICE does not ask whether the person fears the new country. If the person affirmatively says so, USCIS screens the claim. A person who passes goes back to immigration court or the Board of Immigration Appeals. A person who does not pass is removed.

The memo applies to people who already have a final order of removal. It does not apply to people whose cases are still pending in immigration court.

The case

How D.V.D. reached the Supreme Court.

D.V.D. v. Department of Homeland Security is a class action filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts (No. 1:25-cv-10676) on behalf of people with final removal orders whom DHS seeks to send to a third country.

February and March 2025

DHS issues internal guidance identifying people with final orders to consider for third-country removal, including people granted withholding or CAT protection and people released because their home country would not take them. A March 2025 memorandum from then-Secretary Kristi Noem restates the policy.

Spring 2025

The district court issues a preliminary injunction requiring written notice and a “meaningful opportunity” to raise Convention Against Torture claims before a third-country removal.

June and July 2025

The Supreme Court stays the injunction, and third-country removals resume. ICE issues the July 2025 memorandum that sets the procedures used today.

February 25, 2026

The district court enters final judgment. It declares that class members are entitled to meaningful notice and a meaningful opportunity to raise a country-specific claim before removal, and it sets aside the DHS and ICE guidance.

September 18, 2026

The First Circuit largely affirms. “An individual’s right to contest removal to a country based on a fear of persecution in that country means little if one does not receive prior notice of the intended removal destination,” the unanimous panel writes. It vacates one part of the judgment, on the order in which countries must be considered.

September 29, 2026

The Supreme Court stays the district court’s judgment and agrees to hear the case. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson would have denied the stay. The July 2025 procedures remain in effect. Argument is set for December 9, 2026.

The questions before the Court. Whether the district court had jurisdiction over the claims; whether it could grant class-wide declaratory relief and set aside the policy, given limits Congress placed on lower courts in 8 U.S.C. § 1252(f)(1); and whether the third-country guidance is unlawful under the removal statute, the Due Process Clause, or the law implementing the Convention Against Torture. SCOTUSblog’s preview expects the first two questions, about the power of lower courts, to carry much of the argument.

What could happen

Two ways the ruling could cut.

A decision is expected by the end of the Court’s term, usually late June. The Court could also rule narrowly, on jurisdiction alone, without reaching whether the policy itself is lawful.

If the government prevails
Current procedures continue
Notice
The July 2025 procedures stay in place: removal without further process when assurances are accepted, and otherwise as little as 24 or six hours’ notice.
Fear claims
The burden stays on the person to raise fear of the new country, unprompted.
Courts
A ruling on jurisdiction could limit class-wide challenges in district courts, leaving people to raise claims individually, often in a court of appeals.
If the class prevails
The 2026 judgment returns
Notice
The February 25, 2026 judgment, as modified by the First Circuit, would take effect: meaningful notice of the destination before removal.
Fear claims
A meaningful opportunity to raise a claim about the specific third country before being sent there.
Limits
Third-country removal itself would remain lawful. The case is about process, not about whether DHS may use third countries at all.

Bottom line Either way, the government keeps the authority to send people to third countries. What is at stake is how much warning they get, and whether they get a real chance to say they would be harmed there.

Why this reaches Afghan allies

The people this policy was written for include Afghans.

The Congressional Research Service report does not mention Afghans. But the groups DHS named for third-country removal in February 2025, people granted protection from their home country and people whose home country will not take them back, describe many Afghans. The United States has had no embassy in Kabul since August 2021, Temporary Protected Status for Afghanistan ended in July 2025, and Afghans who won withholding of removal did so precisely because a judge found they faced persecution under the Taliban.

24 hours

That is the standard notice ICE gives before a third-country removal when there are no accepted assurances. Afghans are already among those being sent. Reporting in February 2025 placed Afghan asylum seekers on a removal flight to Costa Rica. In late August 2026, CBS News and the Associated Press reported that at least 12 Afghans were on a flight to the Central African Republic, including a young man an immigration judge had protected from return to Afghanistan, whose brothers served alongside U.S. forces. And on October 30, 2026, an ICE officer stated under oath that a charter of more than 150 detained Afghans would land in Pakistan, with onward transport to Afghanistan, a destination their removal orders did not name. That flight did not depart on November 3.

In a separate case, Project Rousseau, Inc. v. Venturella (S.D.N.Y. No. 1:26-cv-09602), a federal judge on November 6, 2026 barred the government from deporting the specific Afghans identified in that case to Pakistan, Afghanistan, or any other third country pending further order, and required one week’s notice of any plan to remove them. That order covers only the people named in it. A motion for a preliminary injunction is being briefed through December 15.

What this means for Afghan allies

Know your order. Say your fear out loud. Call a lawyer first.

If you do not have a final order of removal

The July 2025 procedures apply to people with final orders. If your case is still open in immigration court, or you have asylum, a green card, or another status, this policy does not reach you today. Keep your case moving and keep every hearing.

1

Know exactly what your order says

Keep a copy of your removal order and any decision granting withholding or Convention Against Torture protection. Know which country is named, and which country you are protected from. Families should keep copies too.

2

If you are told you will be sent to a new country, say you are afraid of it

ICE will not ask. If you fear harm in the country on the notice, say so clearly, as soon as you receive it, and ask that it be written down. Fear of a country you have never seen can still be real, for example if that country deports Afghans to Afghanistan.

3

Call a lawyer immediately, and note the time

Write down the date and time you received the notice and the country it names. The clock may be as short as six hours. Families should photograph every notice and anything the person is asked to sign.

4

Tell us what you are seeing

Attorneys can file a report on JULIE. Families and advocates can use our reporting form. Reports are what let us brief Congress with specifics. AfghanEvac is not a law firm and does not give legal advice or referrals.

AfghanEvac’s position The United States brought these Afghans here because they stood with us, and its own courts found that many of them cannot safely go home. A promise of protection is not kept by sending someone to a country they have never known, on a day’s notice, without asking whether they will be safe there. We are committed to helping families understand this policy accurately and to making sure Congress sees what it does.

Set expectations

What D.V.D. does not decide.

  • Whether anyone, Afghan or otherwise, may be deported to Afghanistan
  • Whether DHS may use third countries at all; the case concerns notice and process
  • Anyone’s underlying removal order, asylum case, or immigration status
  • The rights of people whose cases are still pending in immigration court
  • Whether the policy is lawful today; the September 29, 2026 stay paused the lower courts’ rulings but did not decide the merits
  • The separate New York order in Project Rousseau, which protects only the Afghans identified in that case

Frequently asked questions

The questions people are asking.

Can the United States send me to a country I have never been to?

Yes, under current policy, if you have a final order of removal and DHS finds a country willing to accept you. The law lets DHS turn to other countries when removal to the countries a person is connected to is impracticable, inadvisable, or impossible.

A judge granted me withholding of removal from Afghanistan. Am I safe from deportation?

Not from every country. Withholding protects you from return to Afghanistan, and DHS may not send you there. Federal regulations say it does not stop removal to a different country. If you are told you will be sent somewhere new, say right away if you fear that country.

How much warning will I get?

Under the July 2025 ICE memo, generally at least 24 hours, and as little as six in undefined exigent circumstances. If the State Department accepts the receiving country’s assurances, the memo allows removal without further procedures. The lower courts in D.V.D. ruled that this was not enough notice; the Supreme Court has paused that ruling while it decides the case.

Will ICE ask me if I am afraid?

No. Under the current procedures, the person must raise fear of the third country on their own.

When will the Supreme Court decide?

Argument is December 9, 2026. Decisions in cases argued in December usually come by the end of the term in late June, though some come sooner. This page will be updated after argument and again when the Court rules.

What happened to the flight to Pakistan?

The charter scheduled to leave Alexandria, Louisiana on November 3 did not depart. Government filings in New York still describe a plan to remove Afghans “to Afghanistan through Pakistan.” See our Stop the flight page and our Pakistan explainer.

Can Congress change this?

Yes. The Congressional Research Service lists options in both directions. To limit third-country removals, Congress could require more process before transfer, let people contest a third-country designation before an immigration judge, require reporting on agreements, or bar agreements that let receiving countries send people on to a country where U.S. law would forbid their return. To expand them, it could codify the July 2025 memo or create a statutory third-country program.

AfghanEvac statement · November 17, 2026

“Protection that ends at the border of one country is not protection.”

Some of the Afghans in American detention today stood with our troops. Others are the brothers, sons, and daughters of those who did. Some won protection from our own immigration judges, who looked at their cases and found that the Taliban would hunt them. That finding was supposed to mean something.

Instead, the government has been putting them on planes to countries they have never seen, on a day’s notice or less, without so much as asking whether they will be safe when they land. In August, Afghans were flown to the Central African Republic, a country our own State Department tells Americans not to visit. On October 30, ICE swore in federal court that a planeload of Afghans would be flown to Pakistan and driven across the border to Afghanistan. Protection that ends at the border of one country is not protection. It is a detour.

On December 9, the Supreme Court will decide how much process these men and women are owed before they are sent away. The answer should be simple: real notice, in a language they understand, and a real chance to say “I will be harmed there” before it is too late to matter. Congress does not have to wait for the Court. It can require that much today.

To every Afghan family with a loved one in detention: know what the order says, keep a lawyer’s number close, and if a notice names a new country, say out loud that you are afraid. And tell us. We are watching every flight.

Media inquiries: press@afghanevac.org

Go deeper

Read the report, follow the case, and report what you see.

The Congressional Research Service report is a short, nonpartisan overview written for members of Congress. The full record of D.V.D. and the Afghan removal cases is on The Ledger. If you take one thing from this page: a grant of protection from Afghanistan does not stop a removal to somewhere else, so know your order and say your fear out loud.

Related

This explainer summarizes federal policy and pending litigation for informational purposes and is not legal advice. Details are drawn from Congressional Research Service In Focus IF13295, “Immigration Removals to Third Countries” (updated November 16, 2026); the Supreme Court docket in Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., No. 26-426; the First Circuit’s September 18, 2026 decision in No. 26-1212; the November 6, 2026 order in Project Rousseau, Inc. v. Venturella, No. 1:26-cv-09602 (S.D.N.Y.); and news reporting cited above. The law here is moving quickly. For guidance on your own case, consult a qualified immigration attorney or a DOJ accredited representative. AfghanEvac is a nonpartisan 501(c)(3) organization leading the fight to keep America’s promise to our Afghan mission partners and the Americans with whom they served. Questions or corrections: contact@afghanevac.org.